| travisseitler | | | | Wednesday, Apr 19, 2006, 01:26:15 PM | The relational dynamics here are incredible. I really did stop thinking of the Ducks as ducks. |
| Macpaperon | | | | Sunday, Apr 30, 2006, 09:34:29 PM | Questa storia completa e dà senso non solo alla Saga di PDP, ma all'intera storia dei Paperi. |
| Alberto | | | | Sunday, May 28, 2006, 08:35:06 PM | Fascinante! Fantástico! Magnânimo! |
| BenderEsoterico | | | | Friday, Aug 4, 2006, 02:31:14 PM | La produzione disneyana di Don Rosa va divisa in due periodi: "ante Saga" e "post saga". Con la sua Saga, Don ha creato il suo pantheon, definendone i limiti e i punti forti. Pertanto la sua Vita di Paperone deve essere considerata come il punto d'inizio della sua nuova fasa creativa. E questa storia è il punto più alto mai realizzato. |
| JAlbertsen | | | | Tuesday, Oct 30, 2007, 12:58:24 PM | Very touching story - and nice to see Matilda again! |
| Miteuh | | | | Friday, Feb 15, 2008, 06:37:38 PM | Genius! |
| gigikobabouras | | | | Saturday, Mar 15, 2008, 06:29:54 PM | One of Don Rosa's best! |
| Stenens vise | | | | Wednesday, Jun 11, 2008, 08:24:34 PM | Beutiful! Just beutiful! Såhär ska en serie göras!
Intrigerna som ändras mellan karaktärerna är underbara. |
| Scrooge Mcduck | | | | Monday, Aug 4, 2008, 01:25:39 PM | Hjälp va bra!
Bästa Rosan någonsin!
Best Rosa story ever |
| DarkAsh | | | | Monday, Aug 4, 2008, 01:25:49 PM | A modern day classic. |
| Dia-Dia | | | | Monday, Aug 4, 2008, 01:25:49 PM | If only Rosa didn't have such a stiff drawing style... |
| gorjan10 | | | | Monday, Aug 4, 2008, 01:25:54 PM | excelent plot and story and I like the emotions shown between Scrooge and Matilda. Very heartpounding reunion. |
| hahai | | | | Monday, Aug 4, 2008, 01:25:54 PM | Don Rosa ist der schlechtste! |
| islom | | | | Monday, Aug 4, 2008, 01:25:55 PM | Ekstrem god historie, en af de bedste jeg har læst. Rigtig godt med referencer til tempelridderne og deres sagnomspundne skat. |
| Iron | | | | Monday, Aug 4, 2008, 01:25:55 PM | Una delle migliori di Rosa, se non la migliore. |
| new_amz | | | | Monday, Aug 4, 2008, 01:26:02 PM | This story hadn't a significate without "Life and Times". This is only the reason becouse I take this vote. |
| pahan | | | | Monday, Aug 4, 2008, 01:26:03 PM | The best comic of Don Rosa. |
| Sprea | | | | Monday, Aug 4, 2008, 01:26:08 PM | Really one of Don Rosa's best. |
| PdP93 | | | | Monday, Jan 26, 2009, 11:27:28 PM | La migliore del Don. Magnifica è dire poco. |
| Don Rosa Fan | | | | Thursday, Jun 4, 2009, 04:36:29 PM | Touché, très touché par cette fascinante histoire ! |
| csamy | | | | Sunday, Aug 23, 2009, 04:23:54 PM | Pour moi c'est la conclusion de la Jeunesse de Picsou. Une des toutes meilleures de Don Rosa.
This is as for me the conclusion of The Life and Times. One of Don Rosa's best. |
| Mankkop | | | | Tuesday, Nov 17, 2009, 02:09:18 PM | Un Don Rosa felicemente più lieve, che non appare scovraccarico né ridondante.
Non 10 perché, ovviamente, stonano le semplificazioni (e ipocrisie) storiche, che rovinano un po' il plot. |
| Jimbo Slip | | | | Tuesday, Mar 9, 2010, 06:17:07 PM | Ever the dramatist, Don Rosa outlines the reunion between Scrooge and Matilda in a sentimentally trite, Hollywood-ian way. His obsession with the "Indiana Jones"-ian adventure, and the "Da Vinci Code"-ian symbolic decoding posturing, is also reaching its limits here, i.e. we've seen all of this before in better form. |
| Wastel | | | | Thursday, Aug 19, 2010, 01:55:13 PM | Eine der wohl genialsten Storys, die ich je gelesen habe...Top |
| Greg93 | | | | Saturday, Dec 25, 2010, 07:36:42 PM | Λάθος που δεν βρίσκεται στο top-10. Μακράν η πιο συγκινητική, νοσταλγική και ταυτόχρονα απίστευτα γλυκιά ιστορία του Rosa. Η επανεμφάνιση της θείας Ματίλντα είναι το highlight της καριέρας του. Αν δεν είχε αποσυρθεί, θα ελπίζαμε και στην επιστροφή της Βολκάνα, της Ντέλλα και του άγνωστου πατέρα. |
| Appie Aap | | | | Tuesday, Feb 22, 2011, 05:59:36 PM | Sometimes too overtly dramatic, but the story is still very good, with some excellent twists. I like the artwork too. Good to see Mathilda again! |
| themisgreek | | | | Saturday, Apr 23, 2011, 07:54:42 PM | My favourite story with Ducks and undoubtely one of the best ever written!!The emotions it causes you are magnificent!!! |
| montybali@hotmail.com | | | | Sunday, Sep 18, 2011, 03:00:05 PM | My favourite story by Don Rosa and one of the best Disney stories ever...as posted above, the relationship dynamics ARE incredible!!!!!! |
| Scr$$geMcDuck | | | | Tuesday, Oct 25, 2011, 08:35:03 PM | Fantastic story...Don Rosa is a worthy heir to the great Carl Barks... |
| paperinocchio | | | | Friday, Jan 13, 2012, 01:49:25 PM | Fantastica! Storia molto filosofica e con temi tutt'altro che facili. Una delle più belle in assoluto a mio avviso. |
| kalevala1938@hotmail.com | | | | Thursday, Feb 23, 2012, 09:49:33 PM | EXCELENTE HISTÓRIA!!!! |
| hurriflash | | | | Sunday, Mar 25, 2012, 01:43:38 PM | No contest! This is, by far, my story never told in my opinion |
| antonyroma | | | | Friday, Dec 28, 2012, 02:32:06 AM | The ideal closing of Scrooge epos, strongly linked to the last page of "Only a poor old man". Scrooge reveals things that he has never told, talks openly about his nephew, exposes the reasons of his avarice, and shows his real soul, as it was conceived by Carl Barks. The better representation of this wonderful character. A masterpiece! |
| Evan | | | | Wednesday, Jan 2, 2013, 12:11:25 AM | Amazing! Touching, action-packed, historic, incredible art, and by a fantastic author. Best Rosa story, if not Duck story, ever! |
| FynnOsterfeld | | | | Saturday, Jan 5, 2013, 01:01:10 PM | Für mich die beste Story von Don Rosa, einer seiner letzten Comics. Man erfährt viel über Dagoberts Persönlichkeit und seine Vergangenheit. Sehr berührend! |
| jonathand | | | | Monday, Jan 28, 2013, 06:54:34 PM | This story is maybe Don Rosa's best story ever. Amazing. |
| seeilaah@gmail.com | | | | Saturday, Feb 9, 2013, 10:35:53 PM | Such an amazing explanation of all the things:
Why Scrooge keep the "money" well enclosured, why he always travel with Donald and the boys, and a lot of links through the stories from Barks and Rosa. The final story to link everything, the final masterpiece. Congratulations Barks and Rosa. |
| willem | | | | Friday, Feb 15, 2013, 01:02:58 PM | One of my favorites, but Rosa's drawing style have been better. |
| scrooge$ | | | | Thursday, Feb 21, 2013, 04:43:25 PM | The best story ever made! |
| canardeur | | | | Friday, Mar 8, 2013, 11:00:02 AM | La meilleure histoire de Don Rosa ! |
| Donald.totusen | | | | Saturday, Mar 9, 2013, 01:40:53 AM | I think tvist is the best story by Don Rosa. |
| mrDovydas | | | | Saturday, Apr 13, 2013, 04:08:52 PM | Probably the best Disney's comic I've ever read. |
| solariskuba | | | | Tuesday, Jun 18, 2013, 01:09:49 PM | Świetny komiks - aż dreszcze przechodzą! OCH! ZARAZ UMRĘ OD TEGO SUPER KOMIKSU! |
| dannycomicbo | | | | Wednesday, Oct 16, 2013, 11:18:34 AM | Non avrei mai pensato di commuovermi davanti a un fumetto sui paperi. Grazie Don. |
| Fihalho | | | | Sunday, Dec 8, 2013, 12:01:49 PM | Einfach nur gut ! Aber Top 10 ? Viele Barks, Scarpa und Rota Geschichten besser ! |
| evilwithin | | | | Thursday, Dec 12, 2013, 10:26:25 PM | Il perfetto punto d'equilibrio fra tutti gli ingredienti cui Don Rosa ci ha abituato, e al tempo stesso la conclusione che dà senso a tutta la Saga dei paperi. |
| paperalex_blanc | | | | Saturday, Jul 19, 2014, 07:51:02 PM | Tremendamente potente. Una delle migliori di Don Rosa. Unica. |
| Gotham | | | | Friday, Aug 15, 2014, 06:29:24 PM | Don Rosa on his top! |
| drgrillo | | | | Sunday, Sep 21, 2014, 10:23:49 PM | Disney, Templários, conspiração. Don Rosa adicionou tudo nesta história. Fantástica. |
| mimim | | | | Sunday, Oct 26, 2014, 02:44:02 PM | Incredible, intelligent, suspenseful, heartbreaking and at times funny... The summit of Don Rosa's works! |
| SCROOGE19 | | | | Friday, Dec 12, 2014, 02:11:30 PM | Καταπληκτική ιστορία, από τις καλύτερες! |
| Alex P. McDuck | | | | Thursday, Mar 19, 2015, 07:56:16 PM | meine Lieblingsgeschichte meines Lieblingskünstlers :-) |
| m3gr1ml0ck | | | | Tuesday, Apr 14, 2015, 11:08:32 AM | Sorprendente, meravigliosa, intensa, umana (davvero i Paperi qui sono Persone), epica, emozionante.
Con una sorpresa a ogni passo, atipica, una vetta della produzione Disney.
La documentazione e la serietà degli argomenti, così agganciati alla realtà e e privi delle classiche storpiature/parodie Disney (eccetto la parte sul rogo dei Templari?)
Le dinamiche familiari di Paperone, il difficile rapporto con i suoi cari (entrambi defunti, fatto che viene mostrato in maniera esplicita), il segreto di famiglia custodito dalla tormentata Matilda.
La classica caccia al tesoro, con stuzzicanti enigmi "templari" e stanze segrete del castello e trabocchetti (lo "scarico igienico" in cui scivola Paperino!!!) e meccanismi occulti e corridoi sotterranei e altro ancora: la summa di tutti gli imprescindibili elementi che rendono irresistibile la caccia al tesoro mysteriosa.
Grandioso scontro fisico finale col il risveglio del verme che taglia le pietre, mentre Molay porta avanti un dramma a base di armi da fuoco davvero minaccioso e realistico (e raro ai giorni d'oggi).
L'Arca dell'Alleanza, il Trono di Salomone, il Graal (o forse no).
Il passato di Paperone rivisto da Matilda in un'ottica sorprendente, così coerente col Riccagno di Barks: nobile e nello stesso tempo avido, incattivito dalle durezze del mondo ma incapace di dimenticare la sua vera natura.
Ancor più grandiosa della risoluzione della caccia al tesoro, è la catarsi finale di Paperone, che porta le lacrime agli occhi. Il valore di Paperino e nipotini, il significato recondito del cambiamento di "Natale su Monte Orso". Sublime.
. |
| bolupo | | | | Wednesday, Jul 29, 2015, 01:33:31 PM | 我喜欢这个故事，生动地写出了史高治的内心，写出了亲人之间的爱，给史高治的奋斗画出了一个感人肺腑的故事，每每读到史高治的独白与他父亲的家信，禁不住泪流满面。 |
| dave_mala@alice.it | | | | Sunday, May 15, 2016, 09:37:52 AM | The best Don Rosa story. Maybe the best Disney ever made. |
| Lafayet | | | | Saturday, Jun 4, 2016, 07:50:15 AM | One of the best stories ever. Barks is nowhere near to Don Rosa's level. This story would deserve a much better rating. |
| XGorthanX | | | | Thursday, Jun 30, 2016, 08:10:49 PM | La miglior storia di Rosa |
| Asteria | | | | Sunday, Mar 19, 2017, 11:26:12 AM | This story is not flawless. However, I do enjoy the adventure and the touching sentimental moment. The ending is kind of predictable, but still really warmhearted. And no, i don't think this is a sad story. |
| katerini123 | | | | Thursday, Jun 8, 2017, 01:15:29 PM | A MASTERPIECE ! i am sure that this word describes better the whole story. Absolutely,one of the best stories ever, far better from Barks' classics!
|
| Monkey_Feyerabend | | | | Wednesday, Aug 16, 2017, 12:01:53 AM | Ok, we all agree, it's very touching, it's a masterpiece, and so on. But the most epic part is Donald breaking the Graal XD |
| tiogilito | | | | Monday, Apr 16, 2018, 02:55:30 PM | OBRA MAESTRA!!! |
| FlamePegaso | | | | Thursday, Jul 19, 2018, 04:15:41 PM | Essa história é um posfácio perfeito para a Saga do Tio Patinhas. |
| seusilva | | | | Tuesday, Sep 11, 2018, 11:35:18 AM | Uma das melhores histórias dos últimos tempos. |
| 95masa56 | | | | Monday, Oct 22, 2018, 09:19:04 PM | This story always moves me. My personal Don Rosa favourite. |
| Ragz | | | | Thursday, Dec 27, 2018, 12:27:01 PM | This has got to be one of my favourite Rosa stories! The mystery, the humour and of course the family drama are executed wonderfully. |
| tboxman | | | | Saturday, Jan 26, 2019, 02:23:31 PM | Best US story ever written |
| Lucandrea | | | | Monday, May 13, 2019, 04:10:12 PM | Una perla della produzione di Don Rosa: di sicuro tra le tre sue migliori storie |
| joachimramlau | | | | Tuesday, Jul 16, 2019, 05:19:05 PM | One of the greatest Donald Duck-comics of all time... is a mystery fo me, why it not higher rated.
10/10 |
| Sergei | | | | Saturday, May 30, 2020, 06:01:20 PM | Tolle Geschichte! Ein Meisterwerk! Spannend, tolle Schatzsuche und unfassbar rührend – wieso ist diese Geschichte nicht viel höher gewertet?? |
| Alexistss | | | | Wednesday, Jun 3, 2020, 07:00:09 AM | I agree with @Lafayet Don Rosa is so much better than Barks in all levels art and writing! Barks was good at creating new characters that could become famous and used by other artists (like Rosa who used all Barks' characters much better than him) but the truth is that he wasn't very good at writing especially adventure stories... (But again those funny 10-pages stories he made are masterpieces) And in art Barks' first stories were like he was trying to copy Gottfredson's style in Ducks universe. He became better later but still he wasn't much good... And he didn't draw any details at all! At the other side Rosa create a story behind the story! An example: In the story "The Cowboy Captain Of the Cutty Sark" in the 15th page in the 4th panel you can see a mouse putting cotton on his ears (protection from the sound of the explotion) in the next panel a cat is ready to haunt it then in the next page the explotion happens and the cat shocked from the sound stayed there like she was burned and that little story continues until the last panel in 17th page! (but we can see again the cat in the next page's second panel for the last time)
|
| marioandreaaldeghi | | | | Monday, Aug 10, 2020, 06:27:43 PM | Struggente e commovente il finale.
|
| atobibass | | | | Monday, May 2, 2022, 08:22:21 AM | Definetly one of the best comics of Don Rosa |
| xShinatox | | | | Tuesday, Nov 15, 2022, 06:21:40 PM | Probablement l’histoire ou j’ai le plus pleuré. |
| irman | | | | Monday, Feb 20, 2023, 01:59:56 PM | W Carl Barks e Don Rosa! NO ALLE CENSURE NAZISTE! |
| thery67 | | | | Wednesday, Mar 1, 2023, 01:26:58 PM | 10/10 #NOCENSURE #NODITTATURE |
| valentina99 | | | | Friday, Mar 3, 2023, 06:05:08 PM | #NOCENSURA |
